patching...
Breaking: Police Investigate Shooting Near Stedwick Elementary »
Welcome back, Patch Blogger!
Local Voices

Protein Shakes- good or bad?

Yesterday after TurboKick class at proFITClub people started discussion about protein shakes and how much one needs to drink it after workouts.  I want to talk about proteins in general and share some information from Nutritional Consultant prospective.

Many people worried about getting not enough protein. It’s almost impossible to be protein deficient in our culture.  We need protein to build and maintain the tissues. People who need more proteins are growing children, nursing mothers and ones who is recovering from the injuries.

If you eat protein your body needs to burn it as a fuel. Protein molecule is more complicated than molecule in fat or carbohydrates and to get the energy out of it body needs to do more work. When you eat proteins you load a lot of work on your digestive system. Protein in not a clean burning fuel- it contains the nitrogen which leaves ashes in form of amino acids after burning and creates large workload for the liver and kidney which needs to get read of them plus these amino acids can irritate the immune system imbalance in some people.

The protein consumption should be 20-30% (50-100 grams/2000cal) on total calories. People with liver problems or allergies might eat less protein.  There are no needs to use the supplements with protein because you get enough of it with proper diet.  You can eat the animal protein but try to stay off the commercial produce and get the clean hormone free products.  I personally prefer fish and chicken. Chicken’s fat is external to the mussels and could be easy removed by skinning. Beef, lamb or pork has saturated fat embedded inside the mussels and its makes it less healthy. Good idea to minimize the consumption of meat like bacon, hotdogs and salami which made of chemicals such as nitrites and nitrates which  creates the carcinogens in the stomach.

Here are some sources of good proteins: nuts and seeds, eggs, cheese, yogurts, beans, soy products, mushrooms and my lately favorite- quinoa.

Now back to the protein shakes- you might drink them in a moderate amount right after the workout to rebuild the broken muscles tissue, but remember- it loaded with sugar which from one side we need as a curbs source and from other -it’s not very good if you’re working on weight loss.

The good balanced diet should contain 40-50% carbohydrates(less processed sources), 30 % fat and 20-30% of protein.

And for the finishing: High protein and low curbs are a great combination for bad breathJ!

One study I read explained it very well…"When fatty acids are the primary source of energy and carbohydrate is severely restricted, part of the fat particle cannot be metabolized and builds up in the fluids outside the cells. These particles are converted to ketones (an energy source), and unused ketones are excreted in the urine and expired air, resulting in acetone-smelling breath.

---Irina, NC

Recourses: Guide to Optimum health by Dr. Andrew Weil.

Wendy

1:34 am on Friday, May 18, 2012

This is terribly written! Was is proofread? It is full of spelling and grammar mistakes. I couldn't even finish reading it! Surprised that it would be included like this.

Reply
Comment_arrow

Irina

10:49 am on Friday, May 18, 2012

Wendy, thanks for your feedback. I’m sure you’re more knowledgeable than Microsoft Word spell checker and have a better grammar understanding, as well. However, this is not a news story, it’s a personal blog. Generally, blogs are written by different people who what to share their ideas, thoughts and experiences with others. Some of these are written by immigrants whose English might not be as perfect as yours, but at least they try. I’d love to read some of your articles so I could learn from the professional, such as yourself.
On a happy note, try to be more positive and life will be giving you more pleasure and happiness. Have a good day.

Patch_comments_icon

Tiffany Arnold

11:55 am on Friday, May 18, 2012

Irina, what are your thoughts on the different types of protein shakes, since they aren't created equal (e.g. post-workout recovery vs. meal replacement....)? What resources would you point consumers toward for guidance on which ones would be appropriate for their individual health and fitness goals? A marathoner might not be seeking the same sort of protein shake as, say, a body builder, let alone the Average Joe trying to stay in shape.

Reply
Comment_arrow

Irina

1:56 pm on Friday, May 18, 2012

Tiffany, You are right, it is very important to choose the right protein shake. If you are a high-performance athlete looking to boost protein after working out or performing, you probably need a very different shake than someone who is looking for a way to lose weight.

Athletes generally want protein shakes that not only contain protein, but also contain reasonably high levels of carbohydrates to give their body immediate energy, and some amount of fat.

For weight loss- I think people need to find shakes that have very little carbohydrates and fat, and are more filled with protein.

And people such as athletes or ones who engaged in moderate body building would need shake that falls somewhere in the middle- around a 30% -40% of protein.

It’s very important to figure out how much protein you actually need. Most people only need around 3.5 grams of protein for every ten pounds of weight. And don’t forget you getting some of that from your food. Most people actually eat more protein than that, so it is really only people who are working out extensively or building muscle need protein shakes. I personally don’t use protein shake and feel great by getting my nutrients from food and exercising regularly.

Tanya

1:42 pm on Friday, May 18, 2012

i've beeb hearing all the rave about "Shakeology" recently. Tried a sample last week, which was a bit to sweet for my taste. either way. i'd rather have a nice meal i can chew on, then a dinner in a cup :-/

Reply
Comment_arrow

Irina

2:32 pm on Friday, May 18, 2012

Tanya, I know that "Shakeology" is a new product by "Beachbody" and had tried it recently as well. They recommend it as a replacement for one meal a day. It might work for some people, but… I like my real, less processed food with all energy in it.

Leave a comment